Isn’t it just so timely? It’s the first day of school (again) and we all had something to read already –
Mr. Neal Cruz’s opinion piece in the Philippine Daily Inquirer. Most of you have already submitted your reactions and reflections over Twitter and Facebook but along with the back-to-school spirit, I took the enjoyment of writing a “paper” about things I learned today from Mr. Neal Cruz.
Here they are:
1. Opinion writing does not require any research.
“Everyone is entitled to their own opinion.” the old adage goes. Opinions are personal and subjective. Mr. Cruz definitely demonstrated that mere expression of one’s opinion, like a knee-jerk shriek, is enough. Just like the way he simply proclaimed the paintings on EDSA as visual pollution and did not even bother researching on what the Boysen KNOxOut EDSA project really is. He felt that there is no need to probe further if the paint Boysen donated were really “unsalable ones” (like what he mentioned) and not actually air-cleaning paint. So I guess point deductions for me because I actually tried Googling Mr. Neal Cruz before I wrote this. I was wrong to have asked who he is and what Else does he do other than write columns. I guess then Lourd De Veyra mislead us through his inspiring UP MassComm graduation speech, telling us to always “GMG” or Google mo, gago!
2. A trusted broadsheet like The Philippine Inquirer publishes opinion pieces without the checking the facts.
For me, a very poignant moment in the movie Almost Famous was when The Rolling Stones fact checker disapproved young William Miller’s tell-all feature about the band Still Waters. But I guess its fiction after all. In real life, publications don’t have fact checkers. Or maybe fact checkers exist and The Philippine Daily Inquirer has one too. It’s just that The Philippine Daily Inquirer observes lesson number 1 by heart.
3.Modern art has no (public) space in the Metro Manila, only A. Mabini-esque art is allowed.
So I guess my semester nerding over the Philippine Art History is all a travesty! I guess National Artist Victorio Edades’ efforts (of epic proportions) to introduce our country to the Modernist movement in the 1940s til the late 1980s were all just a waste. I bet Neal Cruz would’ve called Edades’ masterpieces “ugly” (like the Boysen murals in EDSA) because they were very far from Edades’ contemporary, Fernando Amorsolo. I also bet Neal Cruz would’ve crucified Banksy if he painted one wall in Manila.
4. Artists who don’t paint nipa huts and fruit-bearing trees are cheaters.
Yes, Baby and Coco Anne of B+C designs did not actually study in the Parsons School of Design, New York and L’ Academie Charpentier, Paris France. They were never trained to draw the simplest form of nipa huts. Jose Tence Ruiz never really learned how to draw farm animals and the brooks and rivers in the UST College of Fine Arts. He can only paint “scary” underwater creatures that give nightmares to a random bus-riding child. (Side note: I consider this child very lucky because he didn’t have to read books and encyclopedias about deep sea creatures, he just had to watch Spongebob!) Lastly, filmmaker, architect and artist Tapio Snellman probably doesn’t know how to paint old Spanish towns like Vigan, Taal and Intramuros because he’s from Finland. Mr. Cruz imprinted in my mind that artists who choose not to create representational art are frauds.
5. It’s way better to allow informal settlers (squatters) to plant vegetables on EDSA islands that to paint EDSA walls with air-cleaning paint.
And I always thought squatting was illegal?
Indeed, my today’s reading was very helpful, insightful and enriched my humanity. For Mr. Neal Cruz, this is for you:
***
For the people experiencing disbelief after reading this: Haven’t you sensed my sarcasm?
but i love those murals… i was seriously amazed the first time I saw the mural in EDSA. I was happy when I realized that public art do exist in our country. As with the Nipa huts and other scenic places in RP as subject, I think they would be quite out of place in EDSA. I’m not very much knowledgeable about art but I do think that it can be very challenging to paint those plumbs. Also, even if plumbs as a subject seems very “ordinary”, I was still awestruck the first time I saw the mural.
Hi Bon!
Thanks for taking thw time to read my blog! Anyways, sarcasm aside, if you were to ask me whether I like the murals, I would say I do. Although some of them are not really my taste, I won’t really qualify them as ugly, not at all. In fact, they are all beautiful. 🙂 also, I think whatmakes all these murals on EDSA beautiful is their environmental cause. They’re not just paintings, they are air-cleaning paintings! I seriouslythink if Mr. Cruz wasn’t lazy to Google this project, he wouldn’t have made such rash opinions.:)
Ahhh, walls with rurality painted all over them… so beautiful, relaxing, and very artsy. HAHA.
PDI is becoming less and less of a “quality” broadsheet read.
HAHAHAHA! I know! I personally think Mr. Cruz’s suggestions were clear signs he does not have that much imagination nor exposure to art. 🙂
Hope PDI would improve though. They used to be really good.
Then it’s time for the parent to teach their son that the mural is just a form of an art. And they are way better than the “art” signs (shapes of triangles, squares, circles) provided by the MMDA a few years back, 🙂
Hi Elgie, what you said is insightful! Art appreciation begins at home. 🙂
As the artist responsible for the ‘ugly’ painting at Cubao I’m grateful for Mr Cruz for initiating an vibrant conversation about art in public space.
I’m even more convinced now, that my decision to celebrate the reality of that amazingly vibrant city, rather than to distract from its problems, was the right one. After all, the series of paintings along the EDSA was commissioned primarily to highlight the problem of air pollution in one of the most polluted cities in the world, using the new paint technology which significantly reduces the amount of deadly pollutants in the air. Also, never forget that EDSA is the one place in the Philippines which firmly stands for change in society and for the power to face the truth. Tapio Snellman, London UK
Hi Tapio,
First of all, I feel so honored to have your comment posted here in my blog.
Honestly, I was saddened by the fact that Mr. Cruz’s opinion was completely subjective and almost baseless. On the other hand, the responses and reactions of many Filipinos are overwhelming and impressive. Mr. Cruz may not have understood your vision and cause, but he is obviously outnumbered by the people who truly understood and appreciated your art and Boysen’s cause for EDSA. So I guess you (with Boysen and the rest of the people involved in this project) have been successful to spark change.
Sincerely,
Cj de Silva
UGLY is such a big word. If Mr. Cruz didn’t liked the fact that EDSA was painted with unusual creatures he could’ve respected the artists commissioned to paint. Some of the paintings were not my taste too, but that doesn’t give me the license to call it ugly and I think it was rather classy and something new. It’s artsy, eccentric and yes not palatable to the common tao. I seriously laughed as I read his opinion written on national newspaper, I thought it was a blog of some sort. 🙂
Hi Lykie!
Thanks for dropping by my blog!
I really understand what you mean! Actually, one realization I have about this issue is that there are two kinds of opinions: the ones you say only to your friends, in private, and the ones you publish in a larger scale (may it be just a tweet, a blog entry or on a national publication.) Feel free to be mean and politically incorrect (by all means) when its the former but I think the latter kind requires a certain amount of elegance, restraint and research. 🙂
Thanks again!
Is the paint really proven to be not harmful to the environment? Coz I have heard the chemicals used “to turn polluted air to clean air” when washed off by the rain, will turn to acid when it stays on the ground and much more harmful when it evaporates.
This might help: http://www.knoxoutpaints.com/howitworks.do
after reading that, I think I can say that totoo na nga, unti unti nang nagdedeterioriate ang Inquirer. BAM.